Forget playing Valentine’s Day Resy roulette.
We asked our community 70k+ locals to spill their secrets on where they actually go to impress a date—no tourist traps or overpriced prix fixe menus allowed.
This is your insider’s guide to the city’s best, from downtown stunners to neighborhood BYOBs.
1. Tre Dita (Lakeshore East)
The newest heavy hitter on the scene, located inside the St. Regis. This is the spot if you want to stay close to the downtown hotels but feel like you’ve been whisked away to a high-end Tuscan estate. The vaulted ceilings and views of the river are pure drama.
The vibe: Ultra-glam. This is a “suit and heels” kind of place.
Pro moves: Order the schiacciata to start. Reservations drop 30 days out on OpenTable, and they go fast. If you’re staying at a nearby hotel like the Hyatt Regency or the Fairmont, this is just a five-minute walk away.
📍401 E. Wacker Dr • The St. Regis Chicago • Chicago, IL 60601
2. Giant (Logan Square)
This neighborhood darling is the definition of “small but mighty.” It’s cramped, loud, and incredibly hard to get into, which only adds to the charm. The food is unpretentious but brilliant.
The vibe: Fun, loud, and very “cool Chicago.”
Pro moves: It’s about a 20-minute Uber from the Loop. You need to be fast on the trigger for reservations (check 21 days out). It’s the kind of place where you’ll be elbow-to-elbow with your date, so it’s better for a fun night out than a serious “will you marry me” moment.
📍3209 W. Armitage Ave., Chicago, Illinois 60647
❤️ Recommended Articles
3. Penumbra (Logan Square)
If you want a mood that is dark and sexy, this is the winner. The name refers to the shadows, and they lean into that look hard. It’s a Latin-inspired steakhouse that feels like a hidden secret.
The vibe: Intimate and romantic. The lights are low enough that you can actually relax.
Pro moves: It’s great for those who want a steakhouse feel without the corporate “business dinner” energy of the downtown spots. The wine list is excellent and more affordable than what you’ll find on Michigan Avenue.
📍3309 West Fullerton Ave. Chicago IL 60647
4. Alla Vita (West Loop)
If your date’s love language is “aesthetic,” take them here. The dining room is stunning, with a canopy of greenery that makes you feel like you’re in a garden, even when it’s ten degrees outside.
The vibe: Very Instagram-friendly.
Pro moves: It’s in the West Loop (the city’s food mecca), so it’s easy to get to from downtown. The rigatoni alla vodka is a crowd-favorite for a reason. Book through their website or Boka Group portal.
📍564 W Randolph St, Chicago, Illinois 60661
5. Gavroche (West Loop)
Classic French vibes without the stuffiness. This spot is cozy, romantic, and feels like the kind of place you’d find on a side street in Paris.
The vibe: Quietly sophisticated. Perfect for a long conversation over a bottle of wine.
Pro moves: It’s a “hidden gem” in a neighborhood full of loud, flashy restaurants. If everything else is booked, check here—it’s a more refined experience that locals love.
📍1529 N Wells St, Chicago, IL
6. Elina’s (West Loop)
This is the “if you know, you know” red sauce joint. It’s tiny, nostalgic, and serves up massive portions of Italian-American classics. It feels like a movie set version of a romantic dinner.
The vibe: Old-school Italian-American.
Pro moves: They don’t have a ton of tables, so set a Resy alert. The portions are huge, so don’t over-order on the appetizers if you want to make it to the main course.
📍1202 W Grand Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60642
7. Monteverde (West Loop)
Sarah Grueneberg’s pasta palace is still one of the toughest tables in the city. Watching the pasta being made by hand at the “pastaficio” while you sip a cocktail is basically dinner theater for food lovers.
The vibe: High-energy and bustling.
Pro moves: Can’t get a table? Show up right when they open and try to snag a spot at the bar. If you’re totally shut out, walk two blocks over to Viaggio for a more old-school neighborhood feel.
📍1020 West Madison Street, Chicago, Illinois 60607
8. Rose Mary (West Loop)
Joe Flamm’s “Adriatic-Italian” fusion is still one of the most talked-about spots in the city. It’s bright, energetic, and the flavors are unique enough to give you something to talk about if the conversation hits a lull.
The vibe: Trendy and lively.
Pro moves: It’s very loud, so if you’re looking for a quiet, whispered dinner, this isn’t it. But the food is some of the best in Chicago. The risotto is a must-order.
📍932 W Fulton Market, Chicago, Illinois 60607
9. White Castle (Multiple Locations)
Yes, seriously. This is a legitimate Chicago cult tradition. Every year, White Castle does a “fine dining” takeover for Valentine’s Day with tablecloths, table service, and heart-shaped decorations.
The vibe: Pure irony and a lot of fun.
Pro moves: This is for the couple that hates the “seriousness” of the holiday. You actually must make a reservation on OpenTable—they do sell out. It’s cheap, hilarious, and a great story to tell when you get home.
📍640 N Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL 60611
10. Tango Sur (Southport Corridor)
The ultimate Southport date spot. It’s an Argentine steakhouse that is perpetually candlelit and always crowded. The best part? It’s BYOB, which helps keep the total bill from spiraling out of control.
The vibe: Dark, crowded, and very romantic.
Pro moves: They don’t take reservations for small groups, so expect a wait. Here is the trick: There’s a CVS and a wine shop within a block. Grab a bottle of Malbec, put your name in, and enjoy the stroll while you wait for your table.
📍3763 North Southport Avenue Chicago IL
The Bottom Line?
Chicago has no shortage of places to eat, but for Valentine’s Day, it’s about the feeling of the room. Whether you’re going for the “wow” factor at Tre Dita or the “ironic” factor at White Castle, the best move is always to plan ahead.
Discover The Chicago You Don’t Know
Join 20,000+ locals getting the inside scoop. Discover hidden gems, secret events, and the best Chicago has to offer. We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
