The 7 Best Boutique Hotels in Chicago (Based on Hundreds of Real Reviews)

You don’t book a boutique hotel in Chicago just for a place to sleep…

You book it for the experience.

But finding one that lives up to the photos is a tricky.

We wanted to fix that.

So we got to work and gathered hundreds of brutally honest reviews from our 40,000 Facebook followers, Reddit threads and Trip Advisor.

We found out exactly what people loved about Chicago’s boutique hotels (and what they hated)

Here’s what we learned, starting with the hotel people couldn’t stop recommending.

1. Our Top Pick: Thompson Chicago

Location: Gold Coast

Why It’s Great: It delivers a sophisticated, stylish experience that consistently wows guests without the chaos of other downtown spots.

Best For: Couples, special occasions, and travelers who appreciate sophisticated design.

In a city full of loud, scene-y hotels, the Thompson stands out for being effortlessly cool.

It’s the hotel that people in our comments and on Reddit consistently recommended for a chic, upscale getaway that actually feels relaxing.

It hits that perfect sweet spot: it’s design-forward and modern, but in a way that feels comfortable, not cold.

The vibe was consistently described as “sexy” and “sophisticated” but, crucially, “not stuffy.”

You’re tucked away in the exclusive Gold Coast, surrounded by beautiful architecture and just steps from the high-end shops on Oak Street and Michigan Avenue.

It feels less like a tourist hotel and more like you’re staying in a high-end, private residence.

Reviewers couldn’t stop talking about the rooms.

They’re praised for being spacious and clean, with hardwood floors and comfortable beds.

But the one detail that came up again and again?

The bathrooms.

People raved about the “great showers,” with many mentioning large tubs and luxurious walk-in showers that feel like a private spa.

The staff also gets high marks for being friendly and helpful, a detail that makes a huge difference.

And the on-site restaurant, Nico Osteria, is seen as a genuine culinary destination, not just a hotel amenity.

Perhaps the most telling endorsement is that the Thompson is the hotel people choose when they’ve been burned by a bad experience elsewhere.

Multiple reviewers who found the more chaotic hotels “annoying” specifically said the Thompson was where they’d be staying next time.

It’s the smart, reliable choice for a fantastic boutique stay.

2. The Experience Pick: Chicago Athletic Association

Location: Downtown Chicago Loop

Why It’s Great: It offers a one-of-a-kind historic atmosphere and an incredible ecosystem of popular bars and restaurants right on-site.

Best For: Social butterflies, first-time visitors who want a story to tell, and people who prioritize atmosphere over a quiet room.

No other hotel in the city sparks more conversation. The Chicago Athletic Association is less a hotel and more a full-blown cultural destination that people either love or hate. Fans are obsessed with its stunning, historic building and incredible “vibe,” with many calling it a “bucket list type hotel” that feels “wildly different” from anything else.

The main draw is the world-class ecosystem inside. You can grab a drink at Cindy’s, the famous rooftop bar with stunning views of Millennium Park, play shuffleboard in the moody Game Room, or sip rare spirits in a tiny speakeasy. Its location, directly across from the park, is a “fantastic selling point” that puts you in the heart of the action.

However, the hotel’s popularity is also its biggest flaw. Dozens of reviews warned that the public spaces are so popular with locals that they become “extremely loud and hectic,” making it difficult for paying guests to find a place to relax. The specific complaints were consistent: slow elevators, impractical bathrooms with poor makeup lighting, and, for unlucky guests, alley-facing rooms with “heavy truck noises and loud banging from 2:30am to 3am.”

3. The Neighborhood Gem: The Robey

Location: Wicker Park

Why It’s Great: It offers stunning skyline views and a true local vibe in one of Chicago’s coolest neighborhoods.

Best For: Repeat visitors, creative types, and anyone wanting an authentic neighborhood experience.

For travelers who are done with the downtown tourist scene, The Robey is the undisputed champion. It’s the hotel our community recommends when you want to feel like you’re actually living in Chicago, not just visiting. Housed in a landmark Art Deco skyscraper in the heart of Wicker Park, you’re surrounded by some of the city’s best independent boutiques, restaurants, and bars.

The absolute showstopper, mentioned in nearly every positive review, is the rooftop bar, The Up Room. It offers jaw-dropping, panoramic views of the skyline that most tourists never get to see. Inside, the hotel’s design is stylish and industrial, and reviewers consistently note the comfortable beds and high-quality linens.

But people were clear about the trade-offs. This isn’t your standard, full-service hotel. Rooms can be on the smaller side, and if you’re facing the tracks, you might hear the El train. The rooftop pool is a tiny “dipping pool” for cooling off, not for swimming laps, and there’s no gym on-site—you have to pay an extra fee to use one down the street.

Ultimately, you’re trading some traditional hotel amenities for a more authentic, cooler experience. If that sounds like a good deal, The Robey is an unforgettable stay.

4. The Exclusive Insider’s Club: Soho House Chicago

Location: West Loop / Fulton Market

Why It’s Great: It offers non-members a temporary key to one of the city’s most exclusive social clubs and its famous rooftop pool.

Best For: Foodies, creatives, and solo travelers looking to socialize.

This was the insider tip that kept popping up in our research. Soho House is a private members’ club, but here’s the game-changer that reviewers shared: you can book a room as a non-member and get access to the club’s incredible world. It’s your ticket past the velvet rope, located in a beautifully repurposed factory in the heart of Fulton Market, the city’s hottest restaurant district.

You aren’t just booking a room; you’re booking a lifestyle. The main draw is the access to amenities that are off-limits to the general public. This includes a full-service gym, a screening room, multiple bars, and the star of the show: the famous rooftop pool. It’s a see-and-be-seen spot with an unbeatable social scene and incredible views, making it the ultimate home base for a summer weekend.

Now, it’s important to understand the deal. This is a private club first and a hotel second. Some reviews noted that guests might need to purchase a temporary “Soho Friends” membership for a fee to get full access, so be sure to check the policy when you book. The experience is less about having a quiet, private retreat and more about immersing yourself in a vibrant, creative community.

If you want to be in the absolute center of the city’s culinary and social scene and love the idea of feeling like a local insider, there is no better choice.

5. The True Luxury Escape: The Langham

Location: River North

Why It’s Great: It sets the gold standard for five-star service, offering a serene and pampering escape from the city’s chaos.

Best For: Anniversaries, milestone celebrations, and travelers who prioritize flawless service.

When the goal isn’t to be seen, but to be flawlessly taken care of, The Langham is the answer. In review after review, the word that came up more than any other was “service.” It’s consistently described as “top-notch,” “impeccable,” and “attentive,” with staff who make guests feel completely looked after. This is the hotel people choose when they want a true escape, a place where, as one person put it, “you feel like you have the entire property to yourself.”

The rooms themselves are an oasis, with reviewers raving about the spacious, elegant design and stunning floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the Chicago River. The Club Level was repeatedly called “worth every penny” for its fantastic food, drinks, and attentive staff, making it a highly recommended upgrade for a special occasion.

But here’s the crucial insider advice from people who’ve stayed there. First, not all views are created equal; many warned that lower-tier rooms can face a parking lot, so booking a “river-view” room is essential for the full experience. Second, while the hotel is a masterpiece, some found the on-site restaurant’s food to be disappointing. And finally, one recent guest noted the advertised 24-hour room service is no longer available, a detail to keep in mind for late-night arrivals.

If you’re celebrating a milestone and want a hotel that delivers on the promise of five-star luxury and tranquility, this is the splurge that actually delivers.

5. The Historic Grand Dame: The Drake

Location: Gold Coast / Magnificent Mile

Why It’s Great: It offers a timeless, step-back-in-time experience with an unbeatable location and legendary historic bar.

Best For: History buffs, traditionalists, and travelers who value classic charm over modern comforts.

The Drake is a true Chicago legend. You don’t stay here for sleek, modern amenities; you stay here for the history, the grandeur, and the feeling of being transported to another era. Reviewers love its prime location at the top of the Magnificent Mile and its stunning, historic lobby. If you get a lake-facing room, the views are absolutely breathtaking.

There are two things people unconditionally rave about. The first is the Afternoon Tea in the beautiful Palm Court, a beloved Chicago tradition. The second is the Coq d’Or, the hotel’s classic, cozy bar. It’s praised for its old-school atmosphere, live piano music, and excellent drinks—a perfect spot to end a day of shopping.

However, recent reviews tell a very consistent story: this grand dame is showing her age. The most common complaint is that the guest rooms are “dated,” with “worn-out furniture,” poor water pressure, and few electrical outlets. Many were frustrated that basic amenities like a mini-fridge now cost extra, something you wouldn’t expect at this price point. One guest even reported their A/C unit was secured with duct tape.

The Drake is a trade-off. You get a memorable, nostalgic experience in one of the city’s best locations, but you have to be willing to overlook rooms that are far from luxurious. As one reviewer summed it up: “While you can feel The Drake was once a swanky place…. those days are clearly past.”

7. The Funky & Modern Gem: EMC2

Location: Streeterville

Why It’s Great: It delivers a fun, memorable stay with a unique art-and-science theme and robot butlers.

Best For: Creative types, tech-savvy travelers, and anyone looking for a hotel with a fun personality.

For travelers tired of boring, cookie-cutter hotels, EMC2 is a breath of fresh air. It’s a hotel with a strong, playful personality, and reviewers loved its quirky art-and-science theme. The vibe is consistently described as “stylish, modern, and trendy,” offering a unique experience that doesn’t take itself too seriously.

The undisputed stars of the show are Leo and Cleo, the hotel’s robot butlers. These autonomous robots deliver items like towels or snacks right to your room, a fun and memorable feature that came up in review after review. Beyond the novelty, the human staff receives overwhelmingly positive marks for being “friendly, helpful, and personable,” making guests feel genuinely welcome. Its Streeterville location is also a huge plus—perfectly walkable to the Magnificent Mile but just far enough away from the worst of the crowds.

But it’s not a traditional luxury hotel. While most found the rooms comfortable and well-designed, some described them as “relatively basic.” A few guests also noted noise from the in-room air conditioning units. The on-site restaurant and valet parking were also mentioned as being pricey, prompting some to use parking apps instead.

If you appreciate creative design and want a hotel with a story to tell, EMC2 offers a uniquely fun and modern stay that stands out from the crowd.

Your Chicago Boutique Stay Awaits

We hope this honest breakdown helps you plan the perfect Boutique Chicago stay, one that truly delivers on its promise.

Need more options?

👉 Browse All Chicago Hotels on Tripadvisor

Looking for things to do in Chicago?

👉 Plan Your Chicago Adventure with CityPass (Save Up To 50% on attractions)